
How to Know If Divorce Is Right for You: Questions to Ask Before You Decide
No quiz can answer this. These questions help you decide for yourself, and show who can help.
Last reviewed: October 27, 2026 by Sarah Bates, Law Clerk, AP.fm, CDS
Some weeks you’re sure. Then a calm Sunday comes along, and you’re not. If you’re trying to work out how to know if divorce is right for you, the honest answer is that no sign or quiz can decide it. You’ll know when you can explain the choice in your own words, with the facts you need, and without a feeling, a deadline or another person making it for you.
I’m Sarah Bates. As a Divorce Coach, I don’t tell people whether to divorce. I help them work out what they’d need to know first, and who can help them find it.
This is general educational information, not legal, tax, financial or mental-health advice. Laws differ by province and territory.
Who decides
You do, not a coach, lawyer or friend
Legal minimum
One year apart, or adultery or cruelty
Trying again
Up to 90 days won’t reset the year
If you’re afraid
Start with safety, not a plan
How to know if divorce is right for you
Start with three questions, in this order. Am I safe? What’s driving this, a pattern or a bad stretch? And what would I need to know before I could decide? Safety comes first for a reason. The other two are where most of the work is.
When someone asks me, “Should I get a divorce?”, I don’t answer it. We sort the question into smaller ones: what you feel, what you know, what you still need to find out, and who can tell you. Each part has someone who can help with it, and none of them is me making the decision.
If you don’t feel safe, start there
If you are in immediate danger, call 9-1-1. If there are threats, coercive control, violence, urgent worries about a child’s safety or a mental-health crisis, get local professional or emergency support first. A decision about the marriage can wait until you’re safe.
Don’t rehearse a confrontation or announce a decision to someone who frightens you. Abuse of any kind, including financial control and isolation from friends and family, is reason enough to get advice. A local shelter or victim services office can help you plan, and a family lawyer can explain your options.
Signs it’s time to divorce, or a rough patch
Every marriage has hard seasons, so one bad month doesn’t answer the question. What counts is whether a problem keeps coming back after you’ve both tried to fix it. These signs suggest something deeper than a rough patch:
Signs the marriage may be over
- Unmet needs you’ve raised many times, and your spouse won’t or can’t meet them.
- The same argument, again and again, with no resolution and more resentment each time.
- You’ve stopped arguing at all, because neither of you thinks it will change anything.
- Contempt: eye-rolling, put-downs, a lack of basic respect. You feel like you’re walking on eggshells.
- Broken trust that isn’t repaired, such as repeated infidelity or hidden debts.
- An addiction your spouse won’t get help for.
- You’re putting far more into the marriage than you get back, and you’ve lost track of who you are.
- You’ve tried couples counselling or honest talks, and nothing changed.
- You live like roommates. Communication has shrunk to schedules, bills and who’s picking up the kids.
Signs it may be a hard season
- The strain comes from outside: a new baby, a job loss, an illness, caring for a parent.
- You both still want to try, and you haven’t had proper help yet.
- You still turn to each other with good news.
Neither list is a scorecard, and a marriage can have outside stress and old damage at once. For more on the signs, my guide on how to tell if your marriage is over goes further.
Recognize the different kinds of readiness
This is the part most checklists skip. You can be ready in one way and not in another, and that’s normal. As I write in my book, Finding Your Way Through Separation:
You may be emotionally ready to separate but unfamiliar with the finances.
Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 4
Emotional readiness
Can you talk about the marriage in the past tense without it taking over the rest of your week? Have you grieved some of what you hoped for? Emotional readiness doesn’t mean you feel fine. It means the feelings aren’t the only thing steering. The emotional divorce and the legal divorce rarely finish together; my guide to emotional divorce explains how to keep one from deciding for the other.
Ready in the everyday sense
Do you know where you’d live, roughly what you’d have to spend each month, and whether you could cover it? If your spouse handled the bills, do you know which accounts, debts and pensions exist? Being financially unprepared is a reason to gather information, not a reason to stay forever. It’s also a common reason people feel stuck.
When one of you is ready and the other isn’t
Often one partner has been thinking about leaving for a long time before saying a word. The other hears it for the first time and is in shock. Neither of you is doing it wrong. You don’t have to match each other’s emotional pace, though you do need a workable way to keep necessary decisions moving.
A low point can start the question
Many people can name the moment the question became real: a declined card, discovering an affair, a holiday that went badly. A low point like that can show you what’s been true for a while. It’s also the worst time to sign, move out or quit a job. Write down what happened, what you felt and what you now want to do. If the answer is “leave tomorrow”, give the feeling some attention (company, a walk, a therapist) while the big step waits for advice.
Questions to ask before you decide
This isn’t a quiz with a score at the end. Take these one at a time, and write your answers down so you can see them next week, when you’re in a different mood.
- Is this a pattern or a rough patch? Has it lasted months or years? Would it still be there if the outside stress went away?
- Have we both tried, with real help? Have you tried couples counselling or a planned conversation, and is your spouse willing to do the work too? Is there anything left you’d both do to save the marriage? One person can’t do it alone.
- What do I want my life to look like in five years? Does that picture include this marriage, with changes, or does it not?
- What am I most afraid of? Being alone, judged, worse off? Name each fear, then ask what you’d need to know to test it.
- Am I ready for the challenges? Housing, money, parenting time, work. Which can you answer now, and which need information?
- What’s the need behind my preference? Wanting to leave might really be wanting calm, respect or space of your own. Wanting to stay might be about the kids’ school or not wanting to start over. Is there more than one way to meet that need?
- Is someone else deciding for me? A friend who keeps saying “just leave”, family who’d be ashamed, or a partner pushing for a fast answer? Their view counts. It shouldn’t decide.
I’d add one more question from Chapter 19 of my book, because it cuts through a lot of noise:
Ask what your future self will need to live with.
Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 19
Should you stay for the children?
Many parents stay in an unhappy marriage to protect their kids. That’s a loving reason, and it isn’t automatically the wrong one. It deserves a clear look, though. Ask yourself what your children see and hear at home now. Is the house calm, or tense and full of conflict? What are they learning about how adults treat each other? Would separating make their days more stable or less, at least once the first year settles?
There’s no answer that fits every family. A quiet, respectful marriage that isn’t happy is very different from a home with daily fighting or fear. If you do separate, how you handle it with the children often affects them as much as the decision itself. My guide on how to tell kids about divorce covers that part.
Work out what you’d need to know first
This is the part I spend the most time on with people at this stage. Most of the stress comes from trying to decide with half the information and all of the pressure. So separate them. I adapted the steps below from Worksheet 10 in my book, which is built for reviewing proposals. The same layout works for this decision:
- Write the choice and the pressure separately. On one side, the choice. On the other, what’s pushing you: a deadline, a threat, wanting the conflict to stop, fear of looking unreasonable. Ask a lawyer which deadlines are real.
- Name the interests behind each option. What would leaving give you? What would staying protect? Mark which needs are essential and which have other answers.
- Compare a realistic alternative. Set divorce beside something you could actually do, like counselling with a clear goal or a trial separation. A perfect marriage isn’t on the table, and neither is a perfect divorce.
- Sort what’s uncertain. Some questions can be answered (what you’d get for the house, what support might look like). Others can’t (how you’ll feel in two years). Get answers to the first kind before deciding.
- List questions for the right professional. Legal questions go to a family lawyer, money questions to a financial professional, and feelings to a therapist. Put each question where it belongs.
- Write down why the choice makes sense to you. Your reasons, the advice you got, the trade-offs you accept, the worries that remain. Leave the decision box blank until the big questions are answered.
Illustrative example: The following composite example is intended only to show the kinds of questions a person may consider. It does not describe a particular client or predict an outcome in another situation.
It’s 10 p.m. in a parked car after a counselling session that went nowhere. A parent of two has been here before, many times. “I keep waiting to be sure,” they say to a friend on the phone. “What if I never am?” Their spouse thinks things are fine, just busy, and doesn’t see why they need counselling at all.
That night they write the page. Pressure: a sister who keeps saying leave, and dread of another holiday like the last one. Needs: a calm home, the kids staying at their school, not feeling alone inside the marriage. Realistic alternative: six counselling sessions with one agreed question, or a trial separation. Questions: what could I afford alone, what happens with the house, how would parenting time work?
The decision box stays blank. They book a consultation with a family lawyer and ask their spouse for six sessions with a clear goal. Their spouse agrees, reluctantly. They still don’t have an answer. They do know what would turn the question into one.
Try a realistic alternative before deciding
Couples counselling works best when both of you want to try and there’s no abuse. A counsellor helps you look at your communication patterns and decide together whether you can repair the marriage, or whether you’d both be better apart. My guide to marriage counselling before divorce covers what to expect. Some couples try a trial separation to get space while they think. That can help, but it has legal and money effects of its own, so get advice before one of you moves out.
Legal facts worth knowing before you decide
I don’t give legal advice, so check how these rules apply to you with a family lawyer in your province. These are the general facts most people ask about:
- Under the federal Divorce Act, a court can grant a divorce when the marriage has broken down. Most people show that by living separate and apart for at least one year.
- Living together again for up to 90 days in total, mainly to try to reconcile, doesn’t restart that one-year clock.
- Justice Canada notes that some couples separate while still living in the same house. A lawyer can tell you what courts look at.
- Only married couples divorce. Provincial or territorial laws cover common-law partners who separate, and married couples who separate without divorcing.
- The date you separated can affect property and support. In Ontario, the Family Law Act generally values property as of the date you separated with no reasonable prospect of getting back together. Other provinces have their own rules. If you’re in Ontario, here’s how Ontario decides your date of separation.
- If you hire a lawyer for a divorce, the Divorce Act says they must talk with you about the possibility of reconciling and tell you about counselling services they know of.
Want help sorting out what you’d need to know?
If you’re stuck between staying and leaving, I can help you turn it into clear questions and the right people to ask, with no pressure to decide anything.
Who can help you decide
| Divorce coach (CDS) | Couples counsellor | Individual therapist | Family lawyer | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Helps with | Sorting questions, readiness, next steps | The relationship and whether it can change | Grief, anxiety, depression, trauma | Your rights, obligations and deadlines |
| Who attends | You alone | Both of you | You alone | You alone |
| Tells you whether to divorce? | No | No | No | No, but explains the legal effects |
| Gives legal advice? | No | No | No | Yes |
| Good time to use | When you’re overwhelmed or stuck | When you both want to try | When feelings get in the way of daily life | Before you move out, sign or agree to anything |
A divorce coach works with one person and doesn’t take sides in the relationship. I explain the role in more detail in what a divorce coach does. If you both decide to separate later, a mediator is neutral, helps both of you work toward agreements and doesn’t give either of you individual legal advice. Independent legal advice may be a good idea before you finalize any agreement.
If your mental health is suffering and you’re struggling to get through the day, a therapist or your doctor is the right first call. That part isn’t a job for a divorce coach. If you’re thinking about suicide, call or text 9-8-8, any time, anywhere in Canada.
Common misconceptions about divorce
- Divorce means you failed. Ending a marriage can be a sign you’ve recognized something isn’t working. Plenty of people who tried hard still separate.
- Staying is always better for the kids. It depends on what home is like for them now and what it would be like after.
- You’ll be alone forever. The fear is real, but it’s a prediction. Many people build new friendships and relationships after divorce.
- You have to be 100% sure. Few people are. You need enough information to make a choice you can explain, and unless there’s a safety issue or a real legal deadline, you usually have time to get it.
Even a well-made decision can hurt. Chapter 19 of Finding Your Way Through Separation puts it simply:
You do not need to feel cheerful about an informed decision.
Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 19
If you decide, start small
If you do decide to separate, your first steps don’t need to be big ones. Don’t move out, empty an account or sign anything until you’ve had legal advice. Plan the conversation with your partner, and if it’s safe to have it, my guide on how to tell someone you want a divorce can help you prepare. If you decide to stay and work on the marriage, set a time to check in with yourself again, so the question doesn’t just go quiet and come back louder.
Not ready to talk to anyone yet? Start the page from the steps above tonight. It takes about 20 minutes, and you don’t have to show it to anyone.
You don’t have to sort it all out today.
If you’ve read this and still don’t know your next step, let’s talk it through. I’ll help you work out what needs attention this week and what can wait.
Questions about deciding to divorce
Should I get a divorce if I’m not sure?
Usually not yet, because being unsure often means an important question is still unanswered
Most people never feel completely certain, so look at what’s behind the doubt. Is it a fact you don’t have yet, like what you could afford on your own or what the law says about the house? Or is it a fear you’d still have with every fact in hand?
Facts can be gathered. A fear may need a therapist, a trusted friend or simply time. If you’re afraid of your partner, don’t wait for certainty: start with safety and local support.
How do you know when it’s time to divorce?
When you can explain the choice in your own words and it still makes sense after you’ve checked the facts
Signs like contempt, abuse, repeated betrayal or years of trying with nothing changing tell you the marriage is in serious trouble. They don’t make the choice for you.
It’s usually time when the signs have lasted, the realistic alternatives have been tried or ruled out, and you’ve answered the big questions about money, housing, children and the law.
Is it normal to feel relief and guilt at the same time?
Yes, mixed feelings are common, and grief can sit right beside relief
You can feel relieved that the conflict may end and sad about the future you planned. You might also feel guilty about the children, your family or your partner. None of that means you’ve chosen wrong.
If the guilt or sadness stays heavy for weeks, or starts getting in the way of sleep, work or caring for your kids, talk to a therapist or your doctor. If you’re thinking about suicide, call or text 9-8-8 any time in Canada.
Do I need a reason to get a divorce in Canada?
You need to show the marriage has broken down, most often by living apart for at least one year
Under the federal Divorce Act, a court can grant a divorce when a marriage has broken down. Justice Canada explains the three ways to show that: you’ve lived apart for at least one year, your spouse has been physically or mentally cruel to you, or your spouse has committed adultery.
You can apply before the year is up, but the divorce can’t be granted until you’ve lived apart for a full year. Only married couples divorce. Common-law partners who separate fall under provincial or territorial law, so check the rules where you live.
What if my spouse wants a divorce and I don’t?
You can’t stop a divorce, but you can take time to understand it before agreeing to any terms
In Canada, one spouse can apply for a divorce without the other’s agreement. What you can control is how quickly you agree to terms about money, the home and the children.
Your partner may have been thinking about this for months, while you’re still in shock. You don’t have to match their pace on feelings, but do get legal advice and meet any real deadlines. A therapist can help with the shock.
