
Jewish Holidays After Separation: Planning for You and Your Children
Name each holiday, set sundown times, settle the logistics early and plan for the days your children are away.
Last reviewed: October 27, 2026 by Sarah Bates, Law Clerk, AP.fm, CDS
In 2027, the first Hanukkah candle is lit on the evening of December 24. That’s Christmas Eve. If your parenting plan says one parent always has Christmas Eve and the other has “the Jewish holidays,” that one date can start an argument nobody saw coming. Jewish holidays for divorced parents need their own plan because the dates move every year, each holiday starts at sundown, and the two homes may not observe them the same way.
So here’s my short answer. Get a Hebrew calendar for the next two or three years. Name every holiday you care about, with start and end times. Decide how each one is shared, how the children travel and call on those days, and what happens when a Jewish holiday lands on a school day or on someone else’s holiday. Then write it down. Everything below helps you do that, and helps you look after yourself on the holidays your children spend in the other home.
This is general information, not legal or religious advice. Family law differs across Canada’s provinces and territories, and questions of Jewish law belong with your rabbi.
Start time
Sundown on the evening before
Dates
Move each year with the Hebrew calendar
In the plan
Each holiday named, with times
The get
A separate religious step from a civil divorce
Jewish holidays for divorced parents need a plan
Most holiday schedules in Canada are built around December 25, Easter and the school winter break. My post on co-parenting through the holidays covers that general planning. Jewish holidays add four things a standard schedule doesn’t handle well.
- The dates move. The Jewish calendar follows the moon and adds a month every few years, so Rosh Hashanah can fall anywhere from early September to early October.
- Days begin at sundown. A holiday listed as October 2 on a wall calendar starts on the evening of October 1. A pickup written as “5 p.m. on the holiday” can miss the first meal entirely.
- Some holidays last several days. Sukkot, Passover and Hanukkah each run about a week, with some days more important to your family than others.
- Observance shapes the logistics. In observant homes, driving, phones and screens may be off limits on Shabbat and on the main festival days, and food may need to be kosher (or kosher for Passover).
When the two homes keep the holidays differently, those details stop being background. They become the questions you need to settle with the other parent, ideally months before the holiday arrives.
The Jewish holidays to name in your plan
A clause that gives one parent “the Jewish holidays” sounds simple. It isn’t. Does it mean two days of Rosh Hashanah or one? All of Sukkot? The first two nights of Passover or all eight days? Courts in other countries have had to sort out exactly that kind of wording after the fact. List each holiday by name. This table is a starting point for the conversation:
| When it usually falls | How long | Questions to settle | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rosh Hashanah | September or early October | Two days, from sundown | Who hosts the first evening meal? Who takes the children to services? |
| Yom Kippur | Nine days after Rosh Hashanah begins | About 25 hours, sundown to nightfall | Where do the children break the fast? Are older children fasting? |
| Sukkot and Simchat Torah | Five days after Yom Kippur | About a week, then Shemini Atzeret and Simchat Torah | Which home has a sukkah? Who has the first days and who has Simchat Torah? |
| Hanukkah | Late November to late December | Eight nights | How are the nights shared? What happens when it overlaps Christmas or winter break? |
| Purim | February or March | One day | Who takes the children to the megillah reading and the costume party? |
| Passover | March or April | Seven or eight days, depending on the community | Who has the first seder and who has the second? Is each kitchen kosher for Passover? |
| Shabbat | Every week, Friday sundown to Saturday night | About 25 hours | Do Friday exchanges happen before candle-lighting? |
For actual dates, check a Hebrew calendar such as Hebcal, which also lists candle-lighting times for your city. For the year ahead: Hanukkah begins on the evening of December 4, 2026. Passover begins on the evening of April 21, 2027. Rosh Hashanah begins on the evening of October 1, 2027, and Yom Kippur on the evening of October 10, 2027. Reform, Conservative and Orthodox communities may count some holidays differently, so plan around how your children have actually been celebrating.
Common ways to share the High Holidays
There’s no single right split for Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur and Sukkot. These are the patterns I see most often, with the cost of each:
Alternate the holidays each year
One parent has Rosh Hashanah in odd years and the other has it in even years, with Yom Kippur and Sukkot going the other way. It’s easy to follow and keeps each holiday whole. The cost is that a parent can go a full year without a particular holiday with the children, which hurts most in the first year.
Split each holiday
The children spend the first day of Rosh Hashanah in one home and the second day in the other, or the first seder with one parent and the second seder with the other, swapping the next year. This can work well when the homes are within walking distance. It doesn’t work when one home doesn’t drive on the holiday and the other home is across the city.
One observant home, one less observant home
If one parent keeps the holidays closely and the other mostly takes time off work, the observant parent may have most of the religious days while the other parent takes more school breaks and long weekends. That only works if both parents agree on it. Nobody should feel their Jewish identity is being written out of the children’s lives.
Hanukkah and Passover
Hanukkah’s eight nights give you room. Many parents alternate who has the first night, or divide the holiday into two blocks of four nights. Because Hanukkah can fall on school nights, a short visit to light candles together may suit the children better than an overnight. For Passover, alternating the first and second seders is common, and some families invite the other parent to one seder when they get along well enough. Talk about the food too: a child moving between a kosher-for-Passover kitchen and one that isn’t needs a plan, not a lecture.
Whatever you choose, write down how the holiday schedule fits with the regular one. As I put it in Chapter 14 of my book, Finding Your Way Through Separation:
Check how special arrangements interact with the regular calendar. Record pickup times, locations and transportation responsibilities where needed.
Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 14
Jewish holidays are where that bites. A Jewish holiday that lands on the other parent’s regular weekend has to be covered by a clear rule. So does a holiday that overlaps Christmas, spring break or a long weekend. Most plans say holiday time takes priority over the regular schedule, and many add make-up time on another day for the parent who loses a weekend. Your plan should say which applies.
Questions to settle before you propose a schedule
In my coaching work, holiday planning for Jewish families rarely gets stuck on the calendar itself. It gets stuck on the details underneath it: who drives on yom tov (the main festival days), whether the children can phone the other parent, which home keeps kosher, who pays for High Holiday seats at the synagogue. Grandparents and extended family add their own expectations too, like the same seder table for thirty years. Sort those out first and the schedule is much easier to agree on.
How you raise these questions with the other parent matters as much as the answers. My post on how to deal with co-parenting covers the messages and meetings themselves.
A composite example
Illustrative example: The following composite example is intended only to show the kinds of questions a person may consider. It does not describe a particular client or predict an outcome in another situation.
Two days before their first Rosh Hashanah apart, a mother calls the children’s father about pickup. Their agreement gives him “the first day of Rosh Hashanah.” She has always lit candles at sundown, about 6:45 p.m. that evening, and wants the children at her table until after dinner. He reads “the first day” as starting that evening. “You’ve had every holiday dinner for twelve years,” he says. “I want them at my table this time.” She isn’t trying to keep the children from him. She’s afraid of the first holiday in an empty dining room. He isn’t trying to take over a ritual he never cared about, either. His parents are flying in, and it’s the first Rosh Hashanah they’ll spend with their grandchildren in years.
They get through that year with a compromise: the children go to their father by 5:30 so they arrive before candle-lighting, and their mother has the second day. The longer question is still open. Neither of them knows how they’ll handle Yom Kippur, when he fasts and goes to synagogue all day and she doesn’t. That’s the part they each take to their own lawyer.
Build your Jewish holiday calendar
This comes from Worksheet 9 in my book, which asks you to draw a calendar and test it against more than an ordinary week. It’s also the kind of preparation I do with clients (here’s what a divorce coach does). Here’s the order I’d work in:
- Print two or three years of dates. Use a Hebrew calendar for your city, so you can see how each holiday moves and when it falls on a weekday.
- Mark the start and end times. Write the sundown start and nightfall end for each holiday you observe, not only the date.
- Lay your regular schedule over it. Shade the days the children are already with each parent and circle every clash.
- Add school and work. Jewish day schools often close for the holidays while public schools stay open, and either parent may need time off.
- Note how each home observes. Driving, phones, food and services. Write what you know about the other home without guessing, and ask where you’re unsure.
- Write a proposal with an alternative. Say what you’d like, why it fits the children, and one other option you could accept.
- Take the open questions to your lawyer. Your lawyer can tell you how to word the holiday section so it means the same thing to both of you.
Holidays, milestones and who decides
A holiday schedule is parenting time. A bar or bat mitzvah, Hebrew school, a Jewish day school or summer camp is a different kind of question: a decision about the children’s religious upbringing. Canada’s Divorce Act treats decisions about “culture, language, religion and spirituality” as part of decision-making responsibility, which is separate from the calendar. Chapter 14 of my book makes the same point: agreeing on who has Passover doesn’t settle who decides about a bar mitzvah. Put both on your list for your lawyer.
Treat the first year as a trial run. Agree to review the holiday section together after the High Holidays and again after Passover, while what worked and what didn’t is still fresh. A short review in writing beats a fight next September.
Want help turning your calendar into a proposal?
I can help you map the holidays, spot the clashes and get your questions ready for your lawyer before you talk to the other parent.
Interfaith families: Hanukkah, Christmas and Passover
If one parent is Jewish and the other isn’t, holidays can be easier to divide, because each parent may care most about different days. One parent keeps Christmas Eve and Christmas Day every year. The other keeps the first seder and the first night of Hanukkah. Nobody has to give up their biggest holiday.
Trouble starts when the holidays collide, as Hanukkah and Christmas do in 2027, or Passover and Easter do in some years. Decide ahead of time which holiday comes first in a clash, and say what the other parent gets in return. Some couples agreed during the marriage to raise the children Jewish, with respect for the other parent’s traditions. If that’s your family, use that agreement as your starting point. Children can light candles in one home and decorate a tree in the other. What they shouldn’t have to do is choose between their parents’ faiths or carry messages about them.
If a new partner and their children are part of the picture, my post on a first Christmas as a blended family covers the extra layer of schedules and expectations.
If you can’t agree on the holidays
Most parents work out holidays themselves, with lawyers or with a mediator. A family mediator is neutral. They help both of you talk through the options but don’t give either of you legal advice, so it’s wise to get independent legal advice before you sign anything. A mediator who understands Jewish practice can save a lot of explaining.
If a court has to decide, the rules depend on whether you were married. Under Canada’s Divorce Act, a court making a parenting order considers only the best interests of the child, and one listed factor is the child’s “cultural, linguistic, religious and spiritual upbringing and heritage.” The Act also says that when parents submit a parenting plan they’ve agreed on, the court includes it in the order unless it isn’t in the child’s best interests. If you weren’t married, or you separated without applying for a divorce, provincial or territorial law applies instead (in Ontario, the Children’s Law Reform Act).
The Department of Justice Canada’s Parenting Plan Checklist asks who will care for the children during religious holidays and how you’ll make decisions about their religious upbringing. Those two questions are a good test of whether your plan is finished. Whether your wording will hold up, and what a court in your province might do, is a question for a lawyer, not a divorce coach.
When the children are with the other parent
The first Rosh Hashanah or seder without your children can feel lonely, even if you agreed to the schedule and know it’s fair. You may feel sad, angry or oddly relieved. All of those are normal. If you’re reading this the week before your first seder on your own, you’re far from the only one. It helps to plan your own holiday as carefully as you planned theirs.
- Call before the holiday starts. If the other home doesn’t use phones on yom tov, agree on a call before candle-lighting and another after the holiday ends.
- Go to services or a community meal. Many synagogues and Jewish community centres hold holiday meals, and some have programs for people who are separated or single parents.
- Host someone else. Invite friends or relatives who may also be alone, or join a friend’s table.
- Celebrate on another day. Light candles with your children on another night of Hanukkah, or hold a second seder the weekend after Passover begins.
- Start one tradition of your own. A walk to tashlich, a new recipe, an evening with someone you’ve lost touch with.
- Ask the children what they’d like to keep. Ask which holiday foods and traditions they love most. Listen, then make the decision yourself, so they never feel they chose between homes.
- Do something for someone else. Deliver holiday meals, or visit a seniors’ residence where some people won’t see family that day.
Don’t make your children responsible for how you feel. Tell them to enjoy the holiday, and mean it. Then let yourself enjoy part of yours. In Chapter 16 of my book, I put it this way:
A difficult period can contain ordinary good moments. You do not need to resolve every issue before accepting company or returning to an interest.
Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 16
If the sadness doesn’t lift after the holidays, talk to a therapist or your family doctor. My post on the emotional side of divorce looks at keeping feelings from making every decision for you.
The get and religious remarriage in Canada
A civil divorce from a Canadian court ends the marriage under Canadian law. In traditional Jewish law, a marriage ends with a get, a written document the husband gives and the wife accepts, usually arranged through a beth din (a rabbinical court). Many Orthodox and Conservative communities won’t recognize a remarriage without one. A woman whose husband refuses to give a get is sometimes called an agunah, a “chained” wife. The Israeli film Gett: The Trial of Viviane Amsalem (2014) follows one woman’s years-long wait in a rabbinical court.
Canada’s Divorce Act speaks to this directly. In a divorce case, a spouse can file a sworn statement (an affidavit) saying the other spouse hasn’t removed a barrier to their religious remarriage after a written request. If the other spouse doesn’t show within 15 days, or a longer period the court allows, that the barrier is gone, the court may dismiss that spouse’s applications and strike out their other court papers. There are limits. The court can decline to act if the other spouse shows real religious or conscientious grounds for refusing, and the rule doesn’t apply when the power to remove the barrier lies with a religious body or official (section 21.1). Provinces may have their own rules too, so ask your lawyer which ones apply to you.
This post can only point you in the right direction. Ask your lawyer about the law, and your rabbi about the get. If the get, or anything else, is being used as a threat, or there’s violence or fear in your home, start with safety: if you are in immediate danger, contact local emergency services, and if there are threats, coercive control or violence, seek prompt local professional or emergency support.
You don’t have to sort it all out today.
If you’ve read this and still don’t know your next step, let’s talk it through. I’ll help you work out what needs attention this week and what can wait.
Questions about Jewish holidays after separation
How do divorced parents split Jewish holidays?
Most alternate each holiday by year, split two-day holidays and seders, or let each parent keep the holidays that matter most to them
The right choice depends on how far apart you live, how each home observes and what your children are used to. Name every holiday in your plan, with sundown start times, and say whether holiday time takes priority over the regular schedule.
Do Jewish holidays override the regular parenting schedule?
Only if your parenting plan, agreement or order says so, which is why the holiday section should spell it out
Many plans say holiday time comes first and give the other parent make-up time on another day. Without that wording, every clash becomes a new negotiation. If you have a court order, follow it and ask your lawyer before changing it.
What if we observe Judaism differently?
Plan around what your children have actually been doing, and agree on the logistics each home will respect on holiday days
Talk about driving, phones, food and services before the holiday. A less observant parent can still honour the start times and keep the children’s routine. An observant parent can still accept that the other home celebrates in its own way.
Does a civil divorce in Canada end a Jewish marriage?
Under Canadian law, yes, but many Jewish communities also require a get, a religious divorce arranged through a rabbinical court
Canada’s Divorce Act includes a process for when one spouse won’t remove a barrier to the other’s religious remarriage. Ask your lawyer about the law and your rabbi about the get itself.
How should we handle Hanukkah when it falls over Christmas?
Decide ahead which holiday comes first in a clash, then share the remaining Hanukkah nights and winter break days
In 2027, the first candle is lit on December 24. Interfaith families often keep Christmas with one parent and the first nights of Hanukkah with the other. A short candle-lighting visit on a school night can work better than another overnight.
Related Articles
Co-Parenting and Family Dynamics
