Table of contents
Share Post
Watercolour of a woman reading calmly on a bench in a bright hallway, preparing for family court instead of fearing bias

Worried About Family Court Bias? How to Prepare Instead of Fear

Canadian law tells judges to decide on your child’s best interests. Here’s how to raise real concerns and walk in prepared.

Last reviewed: October 27, 2026 by Sarah Bates, Law Clerk, AP.fm, CDS

If you’re worried about family court bias, here’s the short answer: Canadian law doesn’t let a judge favour a mother or a father. A judge making a parenting order must look only at your child’s best interests, and there’s no presumption for either parent. Judges are still human, and there are proper ways to raise a concern if you think one treated you unfairly. What protects you most, though, is how well you prepare.

A worry I hear often before a first court date sounds something like this: “The judge has already made up their mind about people like me.” Sometimes it comes from a friend’s story, sometimes from an online forum, sometimes from a hearing that went badly. It’s a real fear. You don’t have to treat it as a prediction, and you don’t have to pretend it’s silly either.

The legal test

Your child’s best interests, and only that

Presumption

None for mothers or for fathers

Wrong decision

Ask a lawyer about an appeal, quickly

Judge’s conduct

A complaint to a judicial council

Is there family court bias against fathers or mothers?

Both claims are out there, and both have supporters with strong feelings. Some fathers say judges treat men as weekend parents and believe false allegations too easily. Some mothers say that when they raise abuse, they’re disbelieved or accused of turning the children against the other parent (sometimes called parental alienation). Research from other countries points in more than one direction:

  • In England and Wales, a 2026 report by the non-profit Right to Equality reviewed 91 published family court judgments and found victim-blaming language in 72.5% of them, with mothers’ behaviour scrutinised more closely than fathers’, as reported in The Guardian. The report recommends mandatory bias training for judges.
  • In Australia, a 2025 University of New South Wales study used AI to analyse more than 2,500 parenting judgments from 2001 to 2021. It found stereotypes running both ways: mothers seen mainly as caregivers, fathers judged on their ability to provide, and fathers praised for limited childcare that was simply expected of mothers.
  • In Canada, a small 2024 study led by a University of Ottawa researcher reviewed three court cases across North America. It found racialized fathers were sometimes seen through cultural stereotypes as controlling or unfit, and its authors called for bias training for judges, lawyers and custody evaluators.

None of these studies measures how Canadian family courts decide parenting cases by gender, and solid Canadian data on that question is limited. So be careful with anyone, on either side, who quotes a single number as proof. What’s easier to pin down is what the law asks of a judge.

What the law requires a judge to consider

For married parents who are divorcing, Canada’s Divorce Act says a court making a parenting order takes into consideration only the best interests of the child. The child’s physical, emotional and psychological safety, security and well-being come first. The Department of Justice Canada says plainly that the law doesn’t include any presumptions about parenting arrangements. That cuts both ways: there’s no preference for mothers, and there’s no automatic 50/50 split either.

Since March 1, 2021, the Act no longer uses “custody” and “access.” It talks about decision-making responsibility (who makes significant decisions about a child’s health, education, culture, language, religion and major activities) and parenting time (the time a child spends in each parent’s care). The new words were meant to focus on what children need from each parent, not on who “wins” them.

The factors a judge weighs

The Act lists factors the court must consider. In plain words, they include:

  • your child’s needs, given their age and stage of development, including the need for stability
  • your child’s relationship with each parent, their siblings, grandparents and other important people
  • each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent
  • the history of care of the child
  • your child’s views and preferences, weighed by age and maturity
  • your child’s cultural, linguistic, religious and spiritual upbringing, including Indigenous heritage
  • each parent’s plans for the child’s care, and their ability and willingness to care for the child and to communicate and cooperate
  • any family violence and its impact

Notice what isn’t on the list: your gender. The Act also says the court can’t consider a person’s past conduct unless it’s relevant to their parenting, and it tells the court to give a child as much time with each parent as is consistent with the child’s best interests (section 16). Child support and spousal support are separate issues with their own rules, so ask your lawyer about them on their own.

If you weren’t married, provincial law applies instead. In Ontario, the Children’s Law Reform Act also bases parenting orders on the child’s best interests, and other provinces have their own laws. My post on putting your children’s best interests first looks at what that test means day to day.

Why court can feel unfair even when the law is neutral

Judges are people, and Canada’s judges are held to a clear standard on exactly this point. The Canadian Judicial Council’s Ethical Principles for Judges say judges are impartial and appear to be impartial. Even so, a hearing can feel one-sided for reasons that have little to do with gender:

  • History of care counts. If one parent handled most school runs and doctor’s visits before the separation, that history is one of the legal factors. To the other parent, it can look like favouritism when it’s really the record.
  • The judge sees a sliver of your life. Affidavits (sworn written statements), a few documents and limited court time are all a judge has. If your involvement isn’t written down, the judge can’t weigh it.
  • Early orders are made fast. A temporary order, one that applies while the case continues, is often made on incomplete evidence. It can feel like a verdict. It isn’t the end of the case.
  • Fear changes what you hear. When you’re anxious, a neutral question can sound like an accusation.

None of this means bias never happens. Individual judges, lawyers and assessors can carry assumptions, and the research above shows why people worry. It does mean that before you decide a judge is biased, ask your lawyer whether something else explains the result. If you don’t have a lawyer yet, my guide on how to choose the best family lawyer covers what to ask.

What to do if you think the judge is biased

If a judge said or did something that made you feel prejudged, write down exactly what happened while it’s fresh: the date, the words used and who was there. Then take it to your lawyer. The right route depends on whether your concern is about the decision or about the judge’s conduct, and that’s a question for a lawyer, not a divorce coach.

Ask whether the judge should step aside

A lawyer can ask a judge to step aside from a case (called recusal) if there’s a real reason to think the judge can’t decide it fairly. The bar is high, and disagreeing with a ruling isn’t enough. The Canadian Judicial Council notes that recusal decisions are made by the judge hearing the case, under the law and the court’s rules. A complaint to a council won’t remove a judge from your file.

Appeal a decision you think is wrong

If you believe the judge got the law or the facts wrong, the route is an appeal. An appeal court looks for errors in the decision; it doesn’t rehear your whole case. In Ontario, the courts’ guide to Divisional Court appeals says appeals must generally be started within 30 days of the order. Some temporary orders need permission (called leave) before they can be appealed, and which court hears the appeal depends on the court and the law involved, as the Court of Appeal for Ontario explains. Other provinces have their own rules.

If you represent yourself, the same deadlines apply, and an appeal can bring legal fees, transcript costs and the risk of paying some of the other side’s costs. Talk to a lawyer right away. For more on what appeals and trials can and can’t do, see my guide to what family court can and can’t do for you.

Complain about a judge’s conduct

If your concern is how the judge behaved, such as insulting remarks, refusing to let you speak or comments about your gender, race or religion, you can complain to a judicial council. Which one depends on the judge:

  • Superior court judges are federally appointed. Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice directs conduct complaints about its judges, including those in its Family Court branch, to the Canadian Judicial Council.
  • In Ontario, complaints about judges of the Ontario Court of Justice go to the Ontario Judicial Council. You make the complaint by letter, and there’s no fee.
  • Other provinces and territories have their own councils for provincially appointed judges.

Know the limit before you write. Both councils say they can’t change a judge’s decision. A complaint looks at conduct, and it won’t change your parenting order. If you want the order itself changed, you need an appeal, or, if your circumstances change later, ask your lawyer about changing the order. In Chapter 12 of my book, Finding Your Way Through Separation, I put the principle this way:

Do not threaten a step you do not understand or intend to take.

Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 12

That includes telling your ex, or the court, that you’ll “report the judge.” Get advice first, then decide.

Preparing your caseAppealJudicial council complaint
What it’s forShowing your involvement and a child-focused planFixing a legal or factual error in a decisionReviewing how a judge behaved
Can it change the order?It shapes the next order or agreementYes, if the appeal court finds an errorNo
Who decidesYou, then a judge or your agreementAn appeal courtThe council
TimingStart nowShort; generally 30 days in OntarioCheck the council’s process
CostYour time, plus any professional helpLegal fees, transcripts and possible costsNo fee at the Ontario Judicial Council
Who helpsYour lawyer, with a coach for organizingYour lawyerYou can write it; a lawyer can advise

How to prepare your parenting case instead of fearing bias

Five years as a law clerk in a family law office taught me how much a court relies on what’s written down. A judge can only weigh what’s in front of them. So the strongest answer to a fear of bias is a file that makes your child’s needs, and your part in meeting them, hard to miss. Chapter 14 of my book is about preparing your contribution to a parenting plan, and it’s where I’d start.

Record your involvement with facts

Keep a short, factual record of what you do for your child: school pickups, appointments, homework nights, activities, who stays home on sick days. Dates and plain descriptions do more than adjectives. As I write in Chapter 12:

“The statement was requested on these dates and has not been supplied” gives a professional something to assess. “They never cooperate” may express your experience but leaves the next step unclear.

Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 12

Some cases also involve a parenting assessment or a report from a children’s lawyer. If one is ordered in yours, prepare for it the same way: facts, your plan and your child’s needs. Keep your records lawful and in proportion. Don’t read your ex’s private messages or record people without advice, and never ask your children to report on the other household. Ask your lawyer what they need and in what form.

Turn your wishes into a parenting proposal

Fear tends to produce grievances. A judge, a mediator or the other parent can do much more with a proposal. Map your child’s real week first: school hours, travel time, child care, activities, health needs and both parents’ work schedules. Then write what you propose and why it fits your child’s needs.

Keep time and decisions apart. A parenting-time calendar answers one question. Decision-making responsibility answers another. Ask your lawyer how each works under the law that applies to you.

Be honest about your limits, too. If a shift means you can’t do Tuesday pickups, say so and suggest something that works. A proposal you can keep is more convincing than a generous one you can’t.

Test the hard weeks, not only the easy ones

Think about holidays, school closures, summer and the day your child wakes up sick on an exchange day. In Chapter 14, I suggest a simple test:

Imagine a difficult week: a child is ill, an adult is delayed and an activity is cancelled.

Sarah A. Bates, Finding Your Way Through Separation, Chapter 14

If your plan has no answer for that week, add one before someone else points out the gap.

A four-week calendar to bring to your lawyer

This comes from Worksheet 9 in my book. Do it on paper before your next lawyer meeting:

  1. Draw four weeks. Mark school days, closures, activities and each adult’s work hours.
  2. Add your proposed parenting time. Include exchange times, locations and who drives.
  3. Count transitions. Note how often your child moves between homes, not only the overnights.
  4. Mark the decisions. List upcoming health, school and activity decisions and how you’d propose sharing information.
  5. Stress-test one bad week. Illness, a late parent, a cancelled activity: who does what?
  6. List your open questions. Take anything you can’t answer to your lawyer or a parenting professional.

On the court day itself, small things help you stay focused. My guide on how to dress for court covers what to wear and how to handle nerves in the courtroom. If you’re a father who feels shut out, my guide to working with a divorce coach as a man may also help.

The letter he didn’t send

Illustrative example: The following composite example is intended only to show the kinds of questions a person may consider. It does not describe a particular client or predict an outcome in another situation.

It’s past midnight, and he’s on page three of a letter to the judicial council. The temporary order gave his ex-wife the children during the school week and gave him alternate weekends. He’s sure the judge took one look at him and decided dads are weekend parents.

At our next session he reads me the line that stung most. “She said the children’s routine has been mainly with their mother. Mainly! I coached hockey for six years.”

“Is the hockey in your affidavit?” I ask.

He’s quiet for a moment. “Not really.”

His lawyer had already told him an appeal of a temporary order would need permission and probably wouldn’t succeed. His ex-wife had her own reasons for asking for the school week. She’d done most of the school-day care for years, and she was worried his rotating shifts would mean late pickups. She wasn’t wrong about the shifts.

So the letter went into a folder, and we started a calendar instead. He wrote down the hockey seasons, the parent-teacher nights he’d attended and the two weekdays his shift pattern actually left free. He proposed Wednesday overnights on top of alternate weekends, with a backup plan for late shifts, and his lawyer took it into the settlement conference.

He still thinks the judge didn’t really listen that first day. Maybe she didn’t. But the next conversation in that case was about his plan.

Whether to appeal, ask a judge to step aside or file a complaint are legal decisions, so make them with your lawyer. My part is helping you get organized, shape your proposal and walk into each meeting knowing what you want to ask.

Worried the judge won’t see your side?

We’ll turn your notes into a factual record and a parenting proposal you can take to your lawyer.

Consider out-of-court options for your parenting plan

A judge only decides your parenting plan if you and the other parent can’t agree. The Divorce Act says parties should try to resolve their issues through a family dispute resolution process, such as mediation or negotiation, where it’s appropriate to do so. And if you do agree on a plan, Justice Canada says the court must include it in its order unless it isn’t in the child’s best interests.

A mediator is neutral. A mediator helps you both talk and look for agreement but doesn’t take sides or give either of you legal advice, so get independent legal advice before you sign anything. Mediation isn’t right for every family. If there’s violence, fear or control, tell your lawyer and the mediator, because it may not be suitable. If you’re in Ontario, Divorce the Smartway explains how child custody mediation works in Ontario.

Sarah Bates, Law Clerk, AP.fm, CDS

Sarah Bates, Law Clerk, AP.fm, CDS

I spent five years as a law clerk in a family law office, and I’m an accredited family mediator (AP.fm) and Certified Divorce Specialist (CDS). In coaching I help one parent organize their record and prepare parenting proposals; I don’t give legal advice, judge your case or act as your mediator.

Not ready to book anything? Tonight, write down three things you did for your child this week, with dates. That’s the start of your record. To see where a coach fits next to your lawyer, read what a divorce coach does.

If there are threats, violence or fear in your home, start with safety. If you are in immediate danger, contact local emergency services. If there are threats, coercive control, violence, urgent child-safety concerns or a mental-health crisis, seek prompt local professional or emergency support.

This article is general educational information, not legal, tax, financial or mental-health advice. Family law rules and court procedures vary by province and territory, so get advice from a qualified professional where you live.

You don’t have to sort it all out today.

If you’ve read this and still don’t know your next step, let’s talk it through. I’ll help you work out what needs attention this week and what can wait.

Questions about family court bias

Are family courts in Canada biased against fathers?

Canadian law doesn’t favour either parent; judges must decide parenting on the child’s best interests, though individual judges can still get things wrong

The Divorce Act sets out no preference for mothers or fathers, and the Department of Justice Canada says the law has no presumptions about parenting arrangements. Factors like the history of care and each parent’s plan for the child do carry weight, and they can favour whichever parent did more of the day-to-day care.

If you think a judge treated you unfairly because of your gender, talk to your lawyer about an appeal or a conduct complaint. Meanwhile, put your energy into a clear record of your involvement and a plan built around your child.

Who is most likely to get custody of a child in Canada?

Neither parent starts ahead; the court decides on the child’s best interests, using evidence about care, plans and the child’s needs

Canada’s Divorce Act no longer uses the word custody. Courts make orders about decision-making responsibility and parenting time, and they give a child as much time with each parent as fits the child’s best interests.

Many parents agree on a plan themselves. If you do, Justice Canada says the court must include it in its order unless it isn’t in your child’s best interests.

Can I ask for a different judge in family court?

Only in limited cases; your lawyer can ask the judge to step aside if there’s a real reason to doubt the judge can decide fairly

This is called recusal, and the judge hearing your case decides the request, under the law and the court’s rules. Disagreeing with earlier rulings usually isn’t enough.

In Ontario, the trial judge is usually not the judge from your conferences. Ask your lawyer how it works in your court.

Will complaining about a judge change my court order?

No; judicial councils review a judge’s conduct and can’t change a decision, so a wrong decision has to go through an appeal

The Canadian Judicial Council handles complaints about federally appointed judges, including superior court judges. In Ontario, the Ontario Judicial Council handles complaints about judges of the Ontario Court of Justice; you write a letter, and there’s no fee.

Both councils say they can’t change a judge’s decision. If you think the order itself is wrong, speak to a lawyer about an appeal right away, because the deadlines are short.

What is the biggest mistake parents make in a custody case?

Letting fear or anger run the case, by attacking the other parent, involving the children or ignoring advice, instead of building a child-focused plan

Judges hear a lot of accusations. What helps is a calm, factual record and a proposal that shows how your child’s week would really work.

Keep your children out of the dispute. Don’t ask them to choose a parent, carry messages or report on the other home.

Sarah Bates

Reach Out: Begin Your Journey to Personal Well-being and Security